"I
HATE MY JOB"
Today
FM: If I may
turn now to Rowan Manahan of Fortify Services. Rowan is
going to talk to us about those people who hate their jobs.
I was reading the other day that in Britain 270,000 people
per day take time out because they are stressed, so if we
were to pro rata that for here it would be ...
20,000+ people absenting themselves because of stress. Are
there really that many people out there who hate their jobs?
Fortify:
Good morning Conal. Let me first say that stress leave
can occur for a multitude of reasons, but to answer your
question, an awful lot of people do hate their
jobs, a significant number of people find themselves in
the 'golden handcuffs' cliché and a large part
of the reason for that is the societal pressure, the family
pressure, the scholastic pressure - you demonstrate an
aptitude for a certain set of subjects at second level
and the system starts (gently or otherwise) shoe-horning
you in that direction; you come to a certain level in
that and, for whatever reason, you find that you are not
deriving satisfaction from it any more.
To
use a Venn diagram model on that, we would advocate that
in order for somebody to be fully happy in the work that
they do there need to be 3 concentric circles: the circle
of Enjoyment (you like what you do), the circle of Skill
(you're good at what you do and it is valuable to the marketplace),
and the circle of Financial Reward (so that you are being
adequately paid for this work). If one of those circles
falls out of kilter the result is a stressed-out, unhappy
puppy.
Today
FM: And what
do you do? I'm thinking of one person I met recently, who
was in this situation. He was a doctor, a very good doctor,
and after 20-odd years of practice, he found out that he
HATED being a doctor and would do anything else. What do
you do? You're not trained to do anything else in particular?
Fortify:
Start reading and thinking - there are endless tomes written
on the subject of transferring or transitioning into a
new career and clearly, the key things you need to identify
are:
 |
What
is it that is making you unhappy? |
 |
What
is it that, conversely, makes you very happy
on the job? |
 |
What
do you have in your skillset that is (a) something
you are genuinely skillful at and (b) is enjoyable
for you and therefore that you will want to bring
with you in your suitcase to the new job? |
 |
Finally,
balance this thinking off with "what will
the market permit me to do?" |
Today
FM: Well that's
a different issue. And isn't that the real issue eventually?
I mean, we'd all love to be paid to sail around the Bahamas
or something, but realistically, we can't ...
Fortify:
No, of course we all can't. Society and the free market
need people to sort the post, and sweep the streets, and
serve in McDonalds etc, etc, etc ... Of course we do.
And there are certain people who will use these jobs in
a transitory way - the 'McJob' as it is now derogatorily
referred to - and certain people who will fulfil those
functions for a large part of their working lives.
But to go back to first principles on the example you gave,
if you are a 30-something or a 40-something who has discovered,
"No, I am not enjoying getting out of bed on a
Monday morning." Indeed, with many of the clients
we would meet, you may be actively stressed out going to
bed on Sunday night knowing that the alarm clock is going
to ring 8 hours later.
The
imperative is to go back to first principles and revisit
your thoughts and dreams from earlier in your life. If you
think of life in 3 phases - Learning, Earning and Yearning
were the three ingredients to a good life that Christopher
Morley identified. In the Learning phase, you have no fetters
on your thinking, you can do anything that you
want. My 4 year-old wants to be a "Princess Ballet
Dancer" and good luck to her, I'm sure she's up
to the task. At some point, she is probably going to discover,
"Oh, I'm not quite good enough to be a Prima Ballerina
and hey - Daddy's not a king ..."
Reality
will slowly set in and that will typically happen towards
the end of the Learning years and heading into those Earning
years. What happens in the Earning years is that your overriding
concern moves from being fun and happiness and clearing
hurdles in terms of exams or what have you; into being very
much about getting security going in your life. We're onto
Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs here, but I would spell
that 'security' with a dollar sign instead of an 'S' at
the beginning - because, as you rightly identify, for most
people that's what it's all about.
You
were talking earlier on in the programme about the cost
of purchasing a home in this nation of ours. Any level-headed
person coming out of the education system now is thinking,
"How on earth am I going to be able to buy so much
as a telephone booth in the greater Dublin area?"
And when you run up against reality, when those constraints
start dropping into place, people lose sight of their dreams.
It's not really about "What is it I really like
to do?" It's more about "What the hell
can I generate the maximum income by doing?
Even if it ends up making me sick to my stomach ..."
Today
FM: Now you're
talking about selling your soul and I did promise at the
top of the programme that we would investigate how to move
on if people hate their jobs. I'm not hearing an answer
here ...
Fortify:
Sure, all we've talked about so far is root cause.
The route out is deceptively simple.
The route out is a period of self-evaluation, followed
by a period of consultation - with friends, family, peers
and perhaps experts on the subject. You take your car
to a garage if it's not running smoothly, many people
now take their careers along for a health check every
now and then. On that basis, you sit down and determine
a narrow number of routes - those that you are going to
be able to go and those that you are going to
be willing to go. And at that stage, still deceptively
simple, you are drawing lines down the middle of pages
- "Where am I going to go next and how am I going
to get there?"
Most
people have this information in their heads. Any self-aware
person knows what they like, what they hate and what their
lines in the sand are. The harsh reality for most people
is the financial constraint which precludes them doing what
they really want ...
Today
FM: ... Which
is mortgage, family, bills and all that. Right. Let us say
that there's somebody lying in bed listening to us this
morning and they have the house and the family and so on.
Realistically they can't change, can they?
Fortify:
Of course they can change. The question is, how drastic
a change can they make and in what timeframe? If you are
a Landscape Gardener now and you want to be an Astronaut.
OK - that's a big leap of faith for NASA to take if they
hire you. But if you are planning to attain the Astronaut
role in 10 years' time, if you make a plan that that is
where you want to go in life, well then you are talking
about taking a succession of planned, baby steps to get
there. What the majority of people do is they drift through
life with no long-term planning horizon. I think the education
system engenders that in us - it's a security blanket
for most people based on a series of short-term horizons.
Today
FM: Do the
kind of people who have long-term plans not freak you out
Rowan? I worry when I meet people who say they want to run
say, NASA, in 10 years' time.
Fortify:
Well, the studies conducted in the Ivy League universities
in the States in the 1950s and 60s indicated that the
very small proportion of people who do
run their life to a long-term plan (about 3% of the population
are 'gifted' in this way) tended to succeed at a very
high level. Given that this was America in the 1950s,
the measure of success used was wealth and that 3% accumulated
more than three quarters of the wealth of the total study
group. 75% of the money flowing into the hands of the
3% who had a long-term plan - and these were not inheriting
their money. There were no silver spoons in the mouth
- they were excluded from the studies.
Today
FM: So the
mistake I made was not being absolutely driven
back about 25 years ago - I didn't think this all out, did
I?
Fortify:
You didn't even write it on the back of an envelope, did
you Conal?
Today
FM: So for
the rest of us mere mortals, in the face of these driven
3%, we take our baby steps. But aren't there those people
out there who, no matter what they want to do, are going
to find themselves unhappy in their working lives?
Fortify:
These people are technically referred to as 'Grumblers'.
They are a very small percentage of the population and
typically, Grumblers are people of very high intelligence,
very low boredom threshold, who have a great deal of insight
and find the political jostling for position and the in-fighting
that occurs in most organisations to be, basically, beneath
them. And they find themselves unhappy as a result.
Today
FM: Rowan,
that's all the time we have this morning. Thank you very
much for talking to us and I think I'll go off now and write
my career plan ... That's Rowan Manahan of Fortify Services.
Fortify:
Thank you Conal, nice to talk to you.